Content
Regardless of age, people and gamers are “curious, and seek excitement and profit,” Wang said. This aligns with CQUniversity Melbourne’s study that concluded positive feelings of enjoyment, financial gain and competition/challenge were among motivators for those who participate in “skin gambling” — gambling virtual items for profit. Johnson was unsure of the effect of loot boxes and gambling mechanics on minors, noting “there isn’t a great deal of data out there” specifically studying the topic. In addition, since publishing the preprint, in relation to Game 8, ‘a Roblox-led program to comply with laws in The Netherlands and Belgium,’ has reportedly caused the removal of user-generated content involving loot boxes from Roblox in Belgium (Carter, 2022).
- Leon Y. Xiao has a masters-level legal degree from the University of London and has researched video game law in depth, including regulation of loot boxes.
- In some cases, players are unaware of the odds for obtaining certain items, particularly rare virtual items, via a loot box.
- Regardless, to achieve a better compliance rate, the Belgian Gaming Commission must then need to carry out its threat of criminal prosecution of non-compliant companies.
- However, what percentage of Belgian players that represents is unknown and by how much (if any) average loot box spending has reduced remains the subjects of further research.
- A Belgian loot box prevalence rate of 0.0% should be found amongst all games studied and amongst those games studied that were deemed suitable for underage players.
On the whole, the committee said the industry was reluctant to accept responsibility for its actions, or recognize that its games could promote dangerous overspending. Some industry representatives had been “wilfully obtuse” when answering questions – particularly about what data they collected, how it was used, and the psychological techniques employed to increase player engagement. Video game publishers have been told they must bring in "sufficient measures" to govern player safety, such as protecting vulnerable adults and fully disclosing the odds of getting certain items from loot boxes. Loot boxes are an in-game feature involving a sealed mystery "box" – sometimes earned through playing a game and sometimes paid for with real money – which can be opened to reveal virtual items, such as weapons or costumes. A private members’ bill has been tabled in the Australian Parliament proposing that computer games containing loot boxes be restricted to players over the age of 18. Xiao told the Deseret News that the Newcastle and Loughborough study found potential for microtransactions to be harmful to children, but the percentage of children who actually buy and open loot boxes is not clear. A 1% chance to earn an item would imply that a player would require a maximum of 100 loot boxes to receive the item they want.
Loot box State of Play 2022: Regulatory and policy research developments
In general, when a player receives a loot box, whether earned or purchased, they are going to receive some virtual items—they just don’t know which ones until they access or open the loot box. The odds of receiving a less sought after player is always greater than those for receiving a superstar. The rarity of the superstar cards is often what drove people to purchase pack after pack of baseball cards in hopes of getting lucky. The relevant defendant companies have since decided not to challenge the decisions, partly because these did not set any precedents that future courts must follow.
Austria: Certain loot boxes may be illegal gambling
In a long-awaited call for evidence, it instead told the video game industry to take action to protect young people. “Examining the potential impact of these gambling-esque systems on young players is important, but we should keep in mind it’s certainly not only young people who are likely to be affected, especially given that adults obviously have access to far more money than your average teenager,” Johnson wrote. Excessive and inaccurate, smilies such as this only fuel the moral panic many fall victim to when discussing video games, Xiao said. One challenge to banning loot boxes is that while evidence confirming the link between loot boxes and normalization of gambling is abundant, research stops short of confirming loot boxes cause negative gambling behaviors. But others pointed out that the Belgium Gaming Commission’s definition specifically requires there to be "a game element" in opening the crate, which differentiates loot boxes from trading cards. Loot boxes give random rewards and can be acquired either through gameplay or by spending real cash. Video game loot boxes are "in violation of gambling legislation", according to the Belgium Gaming Commission.
Bingqing Wang, head of user research at virtual reality developer BlooXR Co, has seen the effect of loot boxes on players and the industry alike. Xiao’s past research showed that even Belgium, which enacted a law against loot boxes, has been unable to fully eliminate the virtual chests from games. However, Xiao said that restricting some larger tnt tumble games on the market would still have positive impact on combating deceptive game mechanics. Xiao said three European Union countries — the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and Belgium — have tried to regulate loot boxes. Only Belgium passed a law against the virtual treasure chests, since only there did loot boxes fully meet gambling criteria.
Video game firms face prosecution over gambling by children
If so, players would be entitled to have the money they spent on loot boxes refunded to them. To date, only four countries have active laws regulating or banning the sell of loot boxes, but more are surely on the way. More and more countries have put together reports examining the problem, and the United States and the United Kingdom both have lawmakers calling for laws to be put into place. However, even if laws are passed, developers and publishers will likely still find loopholes. For instance, Bungie removed their version of loot boxes from Destiny, only to replace them with more predatory microtransactions. Time will tell how the political battle plays out but microtransactions aren’t going anywhere anytime soon. Brad Enright, the commission’s program director, said publishers in general, and specifically Electronic Arts, face “a constant battle” against black markets where players resell virtual items and currency for real money.
Current Legal Analysis
Hypothesis 1 would have been accepted had zero, one, or two of the 100 highest-grossing games that were coded contained paid loot boxes. Those that can be bought for real money must now be removed from video games in Belgium. They were “structurally and psychologically akin” to gambling, the report found, yet are used by nearly half of children who play video games. "Many gamers do ascribe discrete financial values to loot box contents – based on purchase or resale price – suggesting that many loot boxes meet existing criteria for gambling regulation," the authors wrote. The upcoming Gambling Act review is set to look at the question, with the UK’s House of Lords already having weighed in to say that loot boxes should be firmly regulated as "games of chance". This blog post will briefly examine loot boxes as a form of gambling that remains largely unregulated, despite a large portion of its consumers being minors, different responses to loot boxes around the world, and the potential regulation of loot boxes. In the context of this paper we are referring to in-game items that provide aesthetic upgrades to a player’s game play where those in-game items can also be traded as commodities on a marketplace within a platform operated by the game’s developer or distributer.
Every Country With Laws Against Loot Boxes (& What The Rules Are)
He noted that while efforts are made to regulate video game loot boxes, no similar effort exists for trading card games’ “booster packs,” which have a near-identical function. But Xiao also questions whether legislators and the public want to dismantle deceptive gambling practices or get rid of video games altogether. The date and time, based on Central European Summer Time (or Central European Time, depending on which was used by Belgium at the data collection period), on and at which paid loot boxes were searched for was recorded. The Country/Region setting of the Apple ID that was used on the coder’s iPhone was set to Belgium to ensure that the Apple App Store that loads is the Belgian Apple App Store.
Also, China has introduced caps on the number of loot boxes that can be bought in a certain day. Content ratings typically indicate the appropriate age group for and type of content included in a video game. Some advocate that even if loot box mechanics are not gambling, they have an addictive effect and therefore this should be reflected in the games rating.
Loot Boxes and Potential Regulation as a Form of Gambling
It is not clear what this will be, though the report specifically states that "the loot boxes must be removed" to come into line with gambling legislation. US authorities decided that games using loot crates did not constitute gambling because players do get some kind of reward when they acquire the boxes. Belgium’s Minister of Justice, Koen Geens, was keen to focus on how children are confronted with loot boxes, calling the mix of gaming and gambling "dangerous for mental health". Despite growing concern about their characteristics and rising popularity, loot boxes remain unregulated in the UK, whereas countries such as Belgium have deemed them to be gambling products. Loot boxes, video game features used by nearly 40% of children, have clear links to problem gambling, according to a study that has reignited calls for them to be regulated as betting products. All interested parties should be clear, that where gambling facilities are offered to British consumers, including with the use of in-game items that can be converted into cash or traded (for items of value), a licence is required.
The goal with Kompu Gacha was to collect a complete set of specific virtual items. Typically, some items in the set were easily acquired but there was always one or more that were harder to get. In April 2020, the ESRB announced a new “Interactive Element”—used to describe disclosures for video games that highlight a game’s interactive or online features that may be of interest but do not influence a game’s rating. In video games, a loot box (also called a loot crate or prize crate) is a consumable virtual item which can be redeemed to receive a randomised selection of further virtual items, or loot, ranging from simple customization options for a player’s avatar or character to game-changing equipment such as weapons and armor. A loot box is typically a form of monetisation, with players either buying the boxes directly or receiving the boxes during play and later buying "keys" with which to redeem them. These systems may also be known as gacha (based on gashapon – capsule toys) and integrated into gacha games. According to the article, potential legislation to regulate loot boxes, as opposed to an outright ban, is likely the best strategy going forward, by establishing a 21-year minimum age requirement for games that include loot boxes.
Even in the United States, lawmakers have proposed legislation to severely limit the use of microtransactions. In 2019, Senator Josh Hawley introduced a bill to congress that would ban loot boxes, and other micro-transactions, in games played by minors, but the bill has not progressed any further. Even so, action is being taken in the United States with the ESRB, an American rating’s board, adding descriptors in their ratings to warn parents about loot boxes. Political resistance to microtransactions is growing around the world, and some countries have aggressively gone after them.
